Are Old Hickory Knives Any Good?

Knives are an essential tool for various tasks, from cooking to woodworking to outdoor adventures. Over the years, countless brands have emerged to offer their unique take on this invaluable tool.

Among them, Old Hickory Knives have carved a special place in the hearts of knife enthusiasts. With a history spanning over a century, these knives have been praised for their durability and performance.

But are Old Hickory Knives any good? In this article, we’ll dive deep into the world of Old Hickory Knives, exploring their history, materials, uses, and much more to answer that question.

The History of Old Hickory Knives

Old Hickory Knives have been around since 1924, manufactured by the Ontario Knife Company in the United States.

The brand has built a reputation for crafting high-quality, dependable knives that have stood the test of time.

The company’s focus on traditional craftsmanship, combined with modern production techniques, has resulted in knives that are both durable and functional.

Materials and Manufacturing Process

High Carbon Steel

One of the primary reasons Old Hickory Knives have earned their reputation is their choice of material.

The blades are made from 1095 high carbon steel, which is known for its excellent edge retention and ease of sharpening.

High carbon steel is also incredibly tough, allowing the knives to withstand heavy use without breaking.

Manufacturing Process

Old Hickory Knives are produced using a combination of traditional craftsmanship and modern manufacturing techniques.

The blades are heat-treated, tempered, and hand-ground, ensuring a razor-sharp edge that can be easily maintained. The handles are made of hardwood, which provides a comfortable grip and adds to the knives’ classic appeal.

Blade Types and Styles

Old Hickory offers a variety of blade styles and sizes to cater to different tasks. From paring knives and butcher knives to cleavers and slicing knives, there’s an Old Hickory knife for every purpose.

The versatility of these knives makes them a popular choice for both professional chefs and home cooks alike.

Handle Materials and Construction

The handles of Old Hickory Knives are made from hardwood, typically hickory, which is known for its durability and resistance to wear.

The handles are secured to the blade with brass rivets, ensuring a solid and sturdy construction. These handles not only offer a comfortable grip but also add an attractive, vintage look to the knives.

Sharpening Old Hickory Knives

One of the advantages of using high carbon steel is the ease of sharpening. Old Hickory Knives can be easily sharpened using a whetstone or a honing rod, and the edge can be maintained with regular stropping.

This makes them a great choice for those who appreciate the ability to maintain their knives without professional assistance.

Uses for Old Hickory Knives

Kitchen and Food Preparation

Old Hickory Knives are versatile tools that excel in various tasks in the kitchen. From slicing fruits and vegetables to cutting meat and fish, these knives make food preparation a breeze.

Outdoor and Survival

The toughness and durability of Old Hickory Knives also make them suitable for outdoor and survival situations.

They can be used for tasks such as cutting rope, carving wood, or even dressing game in the field. Their sturdy construction ensures they can handle the demands of the great outdoors.

Woodworking and Carving

The precise edge and comfortable grip of Old Hickory Knives make them a popular choice among woodworkers and carvers.

They are ideal for detailed work, allowing artisans to create intricate designs and shapes with ease.

Old Hickory Knives vs. Modern Knives

While Old Hickory Knives have a vintage charm, it’s important to note that they may lack some of the features found in modern knives.

For example, they do not have full tang construction, which is considered essential for maximum strength and durability in contemporary knives.

Additionally, high carbon steel blades are more prone to rust and corrosion than stainless steel alternatives.

However, these factors do not necessarily detract from the overall quality and performance of Old Hickory Knives.

For those who appreciate the traditional craftsmanship, timeless design, and ease of maintenance, these knives remain an excellent choice.

Pros and Cons of Old Hickory Knives


  • High carbon steel blades offer excellent edge retention and ease of sharpening
  • Durable hardwood handles
  • Versatile range of blade styles and sizes
  • Affordable pricing
  • Time-tested reputation for quality and reliability


  • Prone to rust and corrosion if not properly cared for
  • Lack of full tang construction
  • May not offer some features found in modern knives


How do I care for my Old Hickory Knife?

To prevent rust and corrosion, it’s important to keep your knife clean and dry. After use, wash the blade with warm soapy water, rinse thoroughly, and dry immediately. Oil the blade periodically to protect the steel, and store it in a dry place.

Are Old Hickory Knives suitable for heavy-duty tasks?

While Old Hickory Knives are known for their durability, they may not be the best choice for heavy-duty tasks that require extreme force or leverage. The lack of full tang construction may limit their strength in such situations.

Are Old Hickory Knives dishwasher safe?

It’s not recommended to clean Old Hickory Knives in a dishwasher, as the high heat and harsh detergents can damage the wooden handles and cause the blade to rust.

Hand washing and immediate drying are the best methods for maintaining the knife’s condition.


Old Hickory Knives have proven their worth for nearly a century, offering a combination of durability, versatility, and timeless appeal. While they may lack some modern features, their performance and value make them an attractive option for many knife enthusiasts.

With proper care and maintenance, an Old Hickory Knife can be a reliable companion in the kitchen, outdoors, or even in the workshop for years to come.

I'm Justin, co-founder of AllofKitchen and your knife and steel specialist. My extensive experience ensures accurate and hands-on advice on every topic. Turn to me for insights on selecting the best knife or maintaining your steel tools to perfection. Knives aren't just tools; they're an extension of the chef, and I'm here to guide you to the perfect fit.

3.5 4 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x